On March 10, 2025, a powerful tornado touched down near Orlando, Florida, causing significant damage to homes and businesses. This event serves as a stark reminder of the vulnerability of Orange County to such natural disasters and underscores the importance of understanding insurance claims processes to ensure rightful compensation.
Florida is no stranger to tornadoes. In fact, Florida has the highest frequency of tornadoes per 10,000 square miles of any state – even more than Oklahoma. Orange County Florida experiences its share of these twisters. In the past decade alone (2011–2020), Orange County saw 11 confirmed tornadoes, most of them rated EF0 (weak) and one EF1. While many Florida tornadoes are relatively small, they still cause significant destruction. For example, an EF-1 tornado that touched down near downtown Orlando in June 2020 damaged over 42 properties and caused approximately $955,000 in property damage In that incident, an apartment complex sustained over $300,000 in structural losses as the tornado tore through roofs and walls. Each tornado, even minor ones, can leave homeowners and businesses with hefty repair bills. Beyond tornadoes, Orange County also endures hurricanes and severe storms that bring high winds and even spawn more tornadoes. In 2022, Hurricane Ian caused an estimated $206 million in damage in Orange County, damaging 1,727 properties (over 1,200 homes and dozens of businesses).
These “Acts of God” wreak havoc on roofs, structures, and personal property – and residents naturally turn to their insurance for relief. Unfortunately, as many Orange County homeowners have learned, getting your insurance to fully cover storm damage is often an uphill battle.
Storm Damage Insurance Claims: Denial Rates in Orange County and Statewide
After a major storm, thousands of insurance claims pour in from Orange County homeowners and businesses. However, a shocking number of these valid claims end up denied or underpaid by insurers. In the wake of Hurricane Irma (2017), for instance, Orange County policyholders filed over 75,000 insurance claims – but more than 23,000 of those claims were closed without any payment to the policyholder. In other words, roughly one in three Orange County insurance claims after Irma resulted in $0 paid, leaving many families empty-handed in their time of need. Statewide statistics echo this troubling trend. Across Florida, insurers received nearly one million property claims from Hurricane Irma, yet over 311,000 claims were closed without payment.
That means almost one-third of Floridians’ storm claims were essentially denied – despite the extensive wind and water damage those homeowners experienced. Fast forward to recent years, and the pattern persists. An independent analysis found that in 2023, several large Florida insurers denied nearly half of the homeowners’ claims they closed. For example, Castle Key Indemnity (an Allstate subsidiary) denied 47.1% of claims, and State Farm Florida denied 46.4%.. When almost half of all storm damage claims go unpaid by certain insurers, it’s clear the deck is stacked against policyholders.
Even Florida’s state-backed insurer is not immune to denying claims. Citizens Property Insurance – often the insurer of last resort – initially drew headlines for allegedly denying 77% of claims after one 2024 hurricane. (Citizens later argued the true figure was somewhat lower, explaining that many claims were under the hurricane deductible or involved non-covered flood damage.) The bottom line: at one point roughly 73% of the nearly 3,000 Citizens claims for that storm had resulted in no payout to the homeowner. No matter how you slice it, tens of thousands of Floridians are left with storm wreckage and no insurance money to rebuild.
Business owners face similar challenges. Commercial insurance claims for hurricane damage are often denied or lowballed at alarming rates. After Irma, for example, over half of commercial property claims in Florida were closed without payment, and business interruption claims fared no better (only about 50% paid) Whether you own a home or a business, the risk of an insurance denial in Florida is high when disaster strikes. Orange County property owners must be prepared to stand up to aggressive insurance company tactics to get the coverage they paid for.
Insurance Companies With High Denial Rates
Floridians should know which insurance companies have been the worst offenders in denying storm claims. Industry data and consumer reports indicate some insurers consistently lead in claim disputes:
- Castle Key (Allstate) – Denied roughly 47% of homeowner claims in recent storms. Allstate’s Florida subsidiaries have gained notoriety for heavy-handed denial practices.
- State Farm Florida – Denied about 46% of claims according to the same 2023 analysis. Many policyholders with State Farm have received “claim denied” letters even for substantial hurricane damage.
- Citizens Property Insurance – In one example, Citizens acknowledged that 73% of its Hurricane Debby claims in 2024 closed without payment (many due to hurricane deductibles and uncovered flood damage). Even this government-backed carrier often leaves storm victims uncompensated.
- Various Regional Insurers – A host of smaller Florida carriers (often now insolvent) routinely denied large portions of claims. Some insurers have been accused of delaying and denying valid claims simply to conserve their cash reserves, especially as several have faced financial troubles.
These statistics aren’t just numbers – they represent thousands of homeowners and business owners being told “No, we won’t pay for your repairs” by their insurer. It’s not uncommon to hear from neighbors that their roof claim was rejected or their flooded interior was deemed ‘not covered’ by wind insurance.
Common Reasons Storm Damage Claims Get Denied
Insurance companies rarely outright say “we don’t want to pay.” Instead, they cite various technical reasons to justify denials or minimal payouts. Here are some of the primary reasons insurers use to deny or underpay storm claims:
- “Wear and Tear, Not Storm Damage” – One frequent tactic is claiming the damage was pre-existing or due to lack of maintenance, rather than the storm. For example, if wind tears off an old roof, the insurer might insist the roof was already in poor condition and blame normal wear-and-tear. By saying the issue was due to homeowner neglect or age, the insurer tries to invoke policy exclusions for maintenance issues.
- Excluded Causes (Water vs. Wind) – After hurricanes or tornadoes, damage often comes from multiple forces (wind, rain, flooding). Insurers often blame the cause that isn’t covered. A classic example: your living room is soaked because a hurricane ripped off part of the roof. The insurer might argue the major damage came from flooding or rainwater (which standard homeowners policies don’t cover) rather than wind – even if wind clearly caused the opening. By attributing destruction to a flood (excluded) instead of wind (covered peril), they deny the claim. This “wind vs. flood” dispute is a common reason for denial in Florida storms.
- Late Notice of Claim – Insurance policies require prompt reporting of damage. If you wait too long to file a claim, the insurer can deny it, claiming the delay made it hard to verify the cause or extent of damage. Florida law now imposes tight deadlines to report hurricane claims. Many claims get denied because the homeowner didn’t notify the insurer within the required window. Always report storm damage as soon as possible to avoid this trap.
- Failure to Mitigate – After a storm, policyholders are expected to make temporary repairs to prevent further harm (like tarping a roof hole). If you don’t take steps to protect the property from additional damage, the insurer may deny related costs, claiming you worsened the loss by inaction. For instance, if rain pours in for days after because a broken window wasn’t boarded up, the insurer could refuse those damages, citing your failure to mitigate.
- Insufficient Coverage or Deductible Issues – Sometimes claims are denied because of coverage gaps. Florida hurricane policies often have a high hurricane deductible (a percent of your home value). If your damage doesn’t exceed that deductible, the insurer pays nothing. Many homeowners are dismayed to find their claim check is $0 because the loss fell just under a deductible. Similarly, if you didn’t purchase a specific coverage (such as flood insurance or law & ordinance coverage for code upgrades), the insurer will deny portions of the claim not covered by the base policy. Always review your policy to understand your deductibles and exclusions.
- Documentation and Paperwork Errors – Insurance companies also deny claims for technicalities like incorrect forms, missing documentation, or alleged misrepresentations. A simple mistake on your proof-of-loss statement or inadequate photos/receipts can give an adjuster an excuse to delay or deny. They may also claim you misreported information on your application or claim forms as a basis to dispute coverage.
Unfortunately, some insurers engage in “bad faith” tactics, where they intentionally delay or deny valid claims without a legitimate reason. Warning signs include the insurer giving you the runaround, offering a lowball settlement far below repair costs, or rejecting your claim with a vague, unjustified explanation. If you sense your claim is being handled unfairly, you’re likely right – and you should seek legal advice on how to respond.
Why Having an Attorney Greatly Increases Claim Success
Given the high denial rates and numerous loopholes insurers use, it’s clear that going it alone puts policyholders at a serious disadvantage. Insurance companies have teams of adjusters, engineers, and lawyers working to protect their bottom line. To level the playing field, homeowners and business owners often need their own advocate – an experienced insurance attorney – fighting for them. Statistics show that hiring a lawyer can make a dramatic difference in the outcome of an insurance claim dispute:
- A national survey found that 91% of people who hired an attorney for their insurance claim received a payout, compared to only 51% who pursued the claim on their own. In other words, having legal representation nearly doubles the likelihood of getting compensated at all.
- The same research found that, even after accounting for attorneys’ fees, **claimants with lawyers ended up with about three times more money than those without. Insurance companies simply pay more – and don’t drag their feet as much – when a skilled attorney is pushing them to honor the policy.
- The insurance industry’s own data (from the Insurance Research Council) shows that 85% of all insurance claim payouts go to those represented by an attorney. It’s telling that insurers pay the vast majority of their dollars to claimants who have a lawyer advocating for them. They know when you mean business.
- Here in Florida, policyholders are often forced to sue to get results. In fact, Florida homeowners file lawsuits against insurers at a rate 18 times higher than the national average due to rampant claim denials. Those lawsuits, handled by insurance attorneys, often compel insurers to finally pay what’s owed. As one independent insurance analyst noted, some Florida insurers practically push customers to sue as a way to stall payouts, abusing their power until a legal challenge arises.
.
Legal representation signals to the insurance company that you won’t accept a denial or lowball offer at face value. An attorney will thoroughly document your damages, bring in experts (contractors, engineers, meteorologists) to prove the loss was storm-related, and negotiate from a position of strength. If needed, a lawyer can file a bad faith claim or lawsuit to hold the insurer accountable. Simply put, when you have an attorney, the insurer knows it can no longer bully you or ignore your claim.
Fighting for Fair Payouts
Real-world examples illustrate how attorneys make a difference. We’ve seen homeowners who were initially offered little to nothing on a valid hurricane claim eventually recover the full cost of repairs after taking legal action. For instance, after a major Florida hurricane, one family’s roof claim was denied on the basis of “pre-existing damage.” They hired an attorney who gathered maintenance records and independent inspections showing the roof was in sound condition before the storm. Faced with this evidence and the prospect of a lawsuit, the insurance company reversed its denial and paid for a full roof replacement – something that never would have happened without aggressive legal pressure.
In another case, a local business in Central Florida suffered severe wind and water damage from a tropical storm. The insurer offered a token sum that didn’t even cover half the repairs, blaming “wind-driven rain” (excluded) instead of wind damage. Once the business owners brought in a lawyer, the claim was re-evaluated. Through expert reports and, eventually, mediation on the eve of trial, the business’s attorneys secured a settlement several times larger than the original offer – enough to fully restore the property and cover lost income. The attorney also uncovered that the insurer had internally classified much of the damage as wind-related despite telling the client otherwise, a classic act of bad faith. Thanks to legal help, that business got the funds it was entitled to under the policy.
These scenarios are common across Florida. Insurance companies often only unlock the checkbook when a skilled advocate forces their hand. Otherwise, they are content to delay, deny, and defend – knowing many individuals won’t have the resources or knowledge to fight back. Don’t let them wear you down or minimize your loss. As the saying goes, insurance companies have lawyers – you should have one too.
Protect Yourself: Consult an Insurance Claims Attorney
Dealing with the aftermath of a tornado or hurricane is stressful enough; fighting your insurance company for the coverage you’re owed makes it even harder. This is where Malik Law steps in to help policyholders in Orange County and across Florida. We are a law firm dedicated to representing homeowners and business owners in insurance disputes. Our legal team understands the tricks and tactics insurers use, and we know how to counter them to get you results.
At Malik Law, we will:
- Review your policy and claim in detail to identify all coverages you can tap and pinpoint where the insurer is failing to meet its obligations. We cut through the confusing policy language for you.
- Gather powerful evidence (contractor estimates, engineer reports, photos, inventories, meteorological data) to build a solid case that your damages are covered and are worth the full amount claimed. We make it hard for the insurer to deny the facts.
- Handle all communication and negotiation with the insurance company. No more endless phone tag with adjusters or being told conflicting information – we take over and press the insurer to do the right thing.
- Fight bad-faith denial or delays. If the insurer is stonewalling, we will use Florida’s consumer protection laws to hold them accountable, including filing suit if necessary. Our attorneys are not afraid to litigate – we have taken on big insurance companies and won.
- Maximize your settlement or award. Our goal is to recover every dollar you are entitled to under your policy. We don’t let insurers get away with lowball offers or half-measures. Whether through tough negotiations or courtroom advocacy, we push for full compensation so you can rebuild and move forward.
Time and again, we’ve seen that having a lawyer on your side is the key to unlocking a fair insurance payout. Don’t assume the insurance company’s first denial or minimal offer is the final word. You have rights as a policyholder, and Malik Law exists to enforce those rights and get you the money you need to restore your home or business.
Don’t Wait – Get Legal Help Now
If you’re in Orange County or anywhere in Florida and your storm damage claim was denied, delayed, or underpaid, it’s crucial to act quickly. Insurance disputes have deadlines, and the sooner you involve a skilled attorney, the better your chances of a successful outcome. Contact Malik Law today for a free consultation about your case. Let our experienced insurance claim attorneys review your situation and advise you on the next steps.
Remember, you paid your premiums for peace of mind – you deserve to have your claim honored when disaster strikes. Don’t let the insurance company add insult to injury after a tornado or hurricane. Fight back with the help of Malik Law. We will stand up for you, handle the heavy lifting, and pursue the maximum compensation you are owed.
Frustrated dealing with your insurance company? Our experienced insurance dispute attorneys can help.
Contact our offices at 407-500-1000 or complete a free case evaluation. Don’t accept “Claim Denied” as the final answer – let us help you turn that denial into the payment you need and deserve. Put the power of our aggressive legal team in your corner.
